Mine is Asylum now. It was City, but only because I rushed through Asylum years ago and wasn't very good at it. All the games have some great parts and fights though.
Agree about the gadgets. Outside of combat they're useful but in combat as you said, a lot do something similar and the only reason to use them is for points, though there is still a bit more to them.
This is another reason why I like Asylum more. There aren't as many useless things and even some unique ones like the triple Batclaw that never returned. Pummel was ok in City, but not having it doesn't take away anything in Asylum. It struck me as no more than combo bloat.
I really like the special move, 'throw', in which Batman picks up a guy and throws him (obviously) but you can choose the direction and launch him into other enemies. I'm not 100% sure if you can be hit while holding them though. It's a special move so maybe not.
Really need to make a topic but I've put the game on hold for others as is my disgusting habit.
Last edited by Birdman on Tue Oct 08, 2019 8:35 am; edited 1 time in total